Fundamental Limitation to Quantum Computers

Quantum computers that store information in so-called quantum bits (or qubits) will be confronted with a fundamental limitation. This is the claim made by Dutch

Electron microscope image of a qubit from Hans Mooij’s research group at Delft University of Technology.

theoretical physicists from the Foundation for Fundamental Research on Matter (FOM) and Leiden University in an article recently published in the journal Physical Review Letters. A quantum computer can only function if the information exists for long enough to be processed. The so-called coherence of the qubit ensures that the quantum information remains intact. The researchers have now discovered that the coherence spontaneously disappears over the course of time and with this the stored information as well. This could pose a considerable problem for the development of a quantum computer. A quantum computer makes use of the fact that a quantum mechanical system &#151 an electron, an atom or even a larger system such as a superconducting quantum bit &#151 can simultaneously exist in two states. Normally, one of the two states disappears as soon as the system comes into contact with the outside world. The coherence then disappears as a result of the decoherence process and the information in a quantum bit is lost. A quantum bit typically consists of a large number of particles, with an unavoidably large number of possibilities to be influenced by the environment and thus be subjected to decoherence. Jasper van Wezel, Jeroen van den Brink (FOM) and Jan Zaanen, all attached to the Lorentz Institute of Leiden University, have now investigated whether it is possible to maintain the coherence in an isolated qubit. Much to their surprise, they discovered that the coherence tends to spontaneously disappear, even without external influences. The degradation process is linked to the occurrence of quantum mechanical spontaneous symmetry breaking. In classical physics, an equivalent example of this process is spontaneous crystallizsation in a solution. At a certain position, a crystal is spontaneously formed, as a result of which the fluid structure is broken. According to the researchers’ predictions, the coherence in some highly promising concepts for qubits will disappear after about a second. Moreover, the smaller the qubits, the faster that process occurs. All of this would seem to pose a fundamental limitation on the development of qubits. Experimental research will now have to demonstrate whether this phenomenon actually occurs.